Defense Europe: Why is France failing to convince?

Wednesday, December 6, 2023

Defense Europe: Why is France failing to convince?

It's (almost) official now, Belgium has chosen, unsurprisingly, to replace its F16s, the American offer based on Lockheed's F35A. And even if the Belgian government takes the greatest precautions not to offend its French neighbor which proposed the Rafale , by simultaneously announcing the launch of the CAMO program aimed at acquiring 450 VBMR Griffon and 50 EBRC Jaguar from France, the murderous comments do not were not long in coming, in the press and on social networks.

As was the case during the Polish or Swedish choices in favor of the Patriot PAC-3 against the Franco-Italian MAMBA SAMP/T, it is above all the weak adherence to Defense Europe which is singled out, with the role of NATO and the supposed subjugation of countries to American power as a corollary. Surprisingly, very few wonder about the reasons for this low support, and even less about what it would be necessary to modify, on the French side, to effectively create this European dynamic.

An “ideal” context for the emergence of Defense Europe

It is clear that the current international and economic context is particularly favorable for the emergence of a European Defense initiative. On the one hand, the return of Russian military power, supported by its Chinese ally, is generating tensions close to those of the Cold War, creating a compelling need for investments in defense for all European countries. On the other hand, the United States appears more and more like a partner that no longer has its former reliability, and whose decisions on the international scene are sometimes more than doubtful. Finally, despite the 2010 crisis, Europe is economically stronger and richer than ever, with an overall GDP exceeding that of the United States.

European differences singled out

However, it seems that European states today favor their differences over their convergences when it comes to Defense Europe. Often referred to as the main obstacle to the rapprochement of the Franco-German couple in matters of Defense, the differences concerning international policy are presented as incompatible by many commentators.

Moreover, if all governments say they are in favor of Defense Europe, the vast majority of them prefer to remain under the protective wing of NATO and the United States, deeming it more reliable and realistic than the project led by France and Germany.

The comparison with the United States at the heart of the problem

LOGO meta defense 70

The rest of this article is reserved for subscribers -

Classic subscriptions give access to all Flash articles, Analyzes and Syntheses, without advertising , from €1.99.

Premium subscriptions also provide access to articles over two years old in the archive, as well as advanced research tools , and to publish two press releases or job offers per month for free in the Partners section ( + Push social networks / application).

Fabrice Wolf
Fabrice Wolf
A former French naval aeronautics pilot, Fabrice is the editor and main author of the site. His areas of expertise are military aeronautics, defense economics, air and submarine warfare, and Akita inu.

For further


Last articles

share Share

French defense exports record a record €27 billion in order intake in 2022

French defense exports have been moving, for many years, between second and fourth place in the world, far behind the United States, but often neck and neck with Russia and Great Britain. In recent weeks, most of the major international players in this field have announced spectacular increases in their exports in 2023, which […]

The Rafale would not interest the Kazakh air forces

The assertion that Astana and Paris have opened discussions regarding the acquisition of Rafale fighters for the Kazakhstan air forces was denied in a brief published by the Tass Agency. However, if the initial information called for caution, the denial, relayed by the Russian press agency, does just as much. There are some […]

Why should France develop, in addition to the FCAS program, a second combat aircraft?

A few days ago, the Belgian Minister of Defense, Ludivine Dedonder, announced in a post on LinkedIn that the agreement giving Belgium observer status within the FCAS program would be signed in the coming weeks. Above all, she specified that her country should join the program which already brings together Germany, Spain […]