What would be the consequences of a failure of the MGCS program?

Wednesday, February 21, 2024

What would be the consequences of a failure of the MGCS program?

- Advertisement -

Since the failure of the meeting between Sébastien Lecornu and Boris Pistorius in Berlin last July , to try to restart the MGCS program for Main Ground Combat System, rumors have been growing that it would now be threatened.

This rumor gained momentum last week, when France announced that it now intended to impose Italy's membership in the program . For France, the arrival of Italy as an equipotential partner would overhaul industrial sharing and the financing of the program, which has now been unstructured since the arrival of Rheinmetall in 2019.

For Germany, on the other hand, it would represent a significant threat to the activity of its two industrialists, Krauss-Maffei Wegmann and Rheinmetall, but also its predominant position within the program itself, due to the unbalanced balance of power. between the two German players and the only French company Nexter.

- Advertisement -

A degraded climate beyond MGCS between Paris and Berlin

Beyond these internal tensions in the program, relations between Paris and Berlin have weakened considerably in recent months, against a backdrop of radical differences on numerous subjects, such as energy and nuclear power, which shape foreign policy, particularly in Africa. and vis-à-vis Ukraine, or on industrial policy, particularly in the automobile sector.

Lecornu pistorius e1689072732457 International technological cooperation Defense | Germany | Defense Analysis
The smiles of Sébastien Lecornu and Boris Pistorius for the photo at the end of the July 2023 meeting in Berlin, mask the absence of solutions to get the MGCS program out of the rut in which it has found itself for three years now.

It is in this extremely tense context that Sébastien Lecornu and Boris Pistorius agreed to meet again during the month of September, precisely to arbitrate the future of the MGCS program. For many observers, particularly Europeans , this meeting could well lead to the end of this cooperation, with it then joining MAWS, CIFS and Tigre III on the altar of the aborted Franco-German projects of 2017.

Such a failure would have numerous consequences, beyond a deterioration of relations between Paris and Berlin. More precisely, three subjects will then have to be quickly arbitrated by France and Germany: the future of the two countries' new generation combat tank programs, that of the 6th generation FCAS combat aircraft program, as well as the future of the KNDS joint venture.

- Advertisement -

Towards two European programs for new generation battle tanks?

If MGCS were to fail, the need for a new battle tank to replace the armored vehicles currently in service such as the Leopard 2, the Challenger 3, the Leclerc or the Ariete, will remain. The most likely hypothesis to date would be that two European programs would then replace it.

The French successor to MGCS

On the French side, we can easily think that Paris and Rome will jointly undertake to develop a new battle tank. Indeed, unlike Germany, they share the same timetable for replacing the French Leclerc and Italian Ariete, by 2035.

MGCS was to allow the replacement of French Leclercs from 2035
MGCS was to allow the replacement of French Leclercs from 2035

In addition, the armies of the two countries tend to exploit similar doctrines, favoring maneuver and mobility over firepower and armor. This is the reason why both the Leclerc and the Ariete were noticeably lighter and more mobile than their German, British or American counterparts.

- Advertisement -

Belgium would also be a major potential partner for a new French tank in cooperation, on the basis of the CaMo program which led Brussels to order VBMR, EBRC and Caesar Mk2 to optimize interoperability with the French Army. Note, however, that the Belgian authorities have not indicated that they intend to (re)equip their armies with battle tanks to date.

Other European countries could join a possible Franco-Italian new generation battle tank program. Thus, Spain, which invests massively to support the development of its defense industry, could be tempted by the adventure, to obtain a greater participation than in the German program.

Greece, too, could see an interest in this, especially since Paris, like Rome, maintains very good relations with Athens, particularly on defense issues. Likewise, Portugal, even Croatia or Serbia, would certainly find a response to their expectations.

EMBT Nexter e1679583822347 International technological cooperation Defense | Germany | Defense Analysis
The EMBT turret presented at the Eurosatory 2022 exhibition could constitute a relevant starting point for a successor to Leclerc and Ariete.

Paris could also turn to non-European partners to develop its program, such as the United Arab Emirates, Egypt, or even Saudi Arabia in the Middle East. This is also the case for India, which we know wants to develop a replacement for its imposing fleet of T-72s, and which also favors lighter and more mobile armored vehicles.

Indeed, Indian tanks must be able to operate on the difficult and steep terrain of the Himalayan plateaus facing China, as well as in the steppes and valleys of Central Asia facing Pakistan. This is the reason why New Delhi imposes a combat mass of less than 60 tonnes in its call for tenders for the replacement of the T-72s.

In fact, Paris would, if necessary, have several different options for developing a new heavy tank program in international cooperation, perhaps even more adapted to French expectations from both an industrial and political point of view.

The German successor to MGCS

Like France, Germany would also have no shortage of potential partners to develop a successor to the Leopard 2. We are thinking in particular of the declared customers of the Leopard 2A8 or A7HU (Norway, Czech Republic, Hungary and Italy). ), but also to other partners close to Berlin, such as Great Britain, the Netherlands, Sweden, Finland, and even Poland.

In such a hypothesis, the new program, led by Berlin, would respond to the current challenges of German industry, the very ones which today have created the internal tensions that have come to threaten Franco-German cooperation. In particular, it is likely that it would aim for a later timetable, around 2045, or even 2050, so as to free up commercial space for the Leopard 2A8, the KF51 Panther and the Leopard 2AX to come.

a kmw leopard 2a7 with trophy aps at nato day 2022 4608 x v0 9cxnnjwz5afa1.jpg International technological cooperation Defense | Germany | Defense Analysis
The Leopard 2A8, and its future successor, the Leopard 2AX, could serve as an interim solution until the arrival of a German replacement for the MGCS

LOGO meta defense 70 International technological cooperation Defense | Germany | Defense Analysis

The rest of this article is reserved for subscribers -

Classic subscriptions give access to all articles without advertising , starting at €1.99.


- Advertisement -
Fabrice Wolf
Fabrice Wolfhttps://meta-defense.fr/fabrice-wolf/
A former French naval aeronautics pilot, Fabrice is the editor and main author of the Meta-defense.fr site. His areas of expertise are military aeronautics, defense economics, air and submarine warfare, and Akita inu.

For further

5 Comments

  1. We have absolutely all the technological bricks to make an insane tank: the 140 mm Ascalon, the promethe system which is amazing, the fire control which surpasses all the others and finally THE engine which revolutionizes everything at Arquus: the completely hybrid crazy with crazy performances…………in short, all we have to do is remove the spiked helmets

  2. Well, I hope that Mr. AURAY is right...
    We must accept, despite the Macronist dreams of European industrial federalism, that Germany has become hegemonic again despite its many internal problems, notably infrastructure. And yet
    it had been possible , in another time, to cooperate to achieve the Transall, the Jaguar, the Milan... other times...
    What we can reproach the President for is not having perceived the cardinal constraints linked to the passage of time , a constant factor...
    France is therefore in an emergency
    and urgent solutions must be found.
    The Chinese play GO, not Chess...Nuclear power is no longer an answer to all strategic impasses

    • We can blame Macron for anything and everything, but in any case nothing about military management since he has been here.
      He tried to fix the Germans and the French (a losing battle), he put back on track an LPM worthy of the name which he respected and recently with his minister, they made all the right decisions that he there is to take (see the excellent articles on the sites on this subject) on many subjects of cooperation or emergency such as the F5 rafale
      And I repeat, we have all the bricks to build the best tank in the world: it gives us just missing the pre-order volume to launch the business (Italy, India Far East)

  3. At least we will have tried to play the partnership.
    I indeed hope that we will have the guts to establish a serious partnership with a major power (India?) or a rich one (Middle East?).
    But we must no longer let ourselves be taken for a ride and waste precious time.

Comments are closed.

SOCIAL NETWORKS

Last articles

share Share

Is Western technological superiority a self-perpetuating illusion?

In a report submitted to the American Congress in 2023, the Pentagon recognizes that the People's Liberation Army has, today, a significant operational arsenal composed of hypersonic ballistic missiles topped with a hypersonic glider, a technology of which the American armies will only actually be provided in 2025, and in sample quantities. This statement may come as a surprise, since […]

Olaf Scholz promises to bring the German defense effort to 2% and to support Ukraine... Again...

Speaking during a visit to a Rheinmetall factory, Olaf Scholz promised that he would take the German defense effort beyond the 2% required by NATO, and that he would increase the military aid provided to Ukraine. For the chancellor, it was a question of responding to the threats made by candidate Trump, and of trying to resume […]

Trump or not, the Russian threat is now the problem of European armies

While the threats made by Donald Trump against Europeans continue to hit the headlines, a report from Russian foreign intelligence services paints a very worrying picture concerning the European military industrial potential developing in the years to come, facing to that of the Russian armies. Indeed, according to this report, […]